Abstract
Random sampling of graph partitions under constraints has become a popular tool for evaluating legislative redistricting plans. Analysts detect partisan gerrymandering by comparing a proposed redistricting plan with an ensemble of sampled alternative plans. For successful application, sampling methods must scale to large maps with many districts, incorporate realistic legal constraints, and accurately and efficiently sample from a selected target distribution. Unfortunately, most existing methods struggle in at least one of these areas. We present a new Sequential Monte Carlo (SMC) algorithm that draws representative redistricting plans from a realistic target distribution of choice. Because it samples directly, the SMC algorithm can efficiently explore the relevant space of redistricting plans better than the existing Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithms that yield dependent samples. Our algorithm can simultaneously incorporate several constraints commonly imposed in real-world redistricting problems, including equal population, compactness, and preservation of administrative boundaries. We validate the accuracy of the proposed algorithm by using a small map where all redistricting plans can be enumerated. We then apply the SMC algorithm to evaluate the partisan implications of several maps submitted by relevant parties in a recent high-profile redistricting case in the state of Pennsylvania. We find that the proposed algorithm is roughly 40 times more efficient in sampling from the target distribution than a state-of-the-art MCMC algorithm. Open-source software is available for implementing the proposed methodology. (Last Revised, December, 2020)
Related Papers and Software
Fifield, Benjamin, Michael Higgins, Kosuke Imai, and Alexander Tarr. (2020). “Automated Redistricting Simulator Using Markov Chain Monte Carlo.”Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics, Vol. 29, No. 4, pp. 715-728.
Fifield, Benjamin, Kosuke Imai, Jun Kawahara, and Christopher T. Kenny. (2020). “The Essential Role of Empirical Validation in Legislative Redistricting Simulation.” Statistics and Public Policy, Vol. 7, No. 1, pp 52-68.
Fifield, Benjamin, Christopher T. Kenny, Cory MaCartan, Alexander Tarr, and Kosuke Imai. “redist: Computational Algorithms for Redistricting Simulation.” available through The Comprehensive R Archive Network and GitHub.